Market Stat Monday: 1800 Club
May 1, 2017 by Lucas Lechuga
Last week, we had the first official installment of the Market Stat Monday series. We checked in on Quantum on the Bay, which is in the process of overcoming some legal battles. One of our readers suggested that we skip next door this week and look into the less dramatic yet equally beautiful 1800 Club, so here we are.
For those who are new to 1800 Club, it was built in 2007 and has 469 apartments within 42 stories. It is a full-service building, pretty much standard to the area. The amenities include pools, gym, 24 hour doorman, valet, and a party room. The building is quite lovely and is also well-kept. It was actually one of the few buildings in the market to earn FHA approval, so FHA buyers could purchase there with low down payment loans. That approval is notoriously difficult for condo buildings, and sadly it expired for 1800 Club in 2014, but the fact that it was achieved speaks volumes of how the building is run. Today, the FHA certification has not been renewed, but there are conventional mortgage programs that allow up to 95% financing on purchases in the building.
There are currently 32 active listings for sale, so 7% of the total units are available for purchase. The average price per foot ranges more drastically than most buildings. The lowest-priced unit is listed for $295/square foot and the highest price per foot is $511/square foot. If you're curious why the gap in pricing is so large, it is because the units in this building have a very different mix of layouts and views. Apartments on the east side of the building have direct bay views, apartments on the west side have sunset views and those located on the south side of the building have partial bay views but also look into the nearly-completed Aria on the Bay. Also, all of the one bedroom plans have either the west view or south view. There is one line that has two bedrooms and a west view, but most of the two bedrooms have south or east views. Because the layouts and views are so starkly different, I've decided to pull the statistics for each segment of the building.
WEST FACING UNITS
There are currently 7 units on the market that face west. These have beautiful sunset views and the asking price averages $380/square foot. The least expensive is apartment 2902, an 841 square foot 1 bedroom that is offered for $278,900 and includes a $2,000 credit toward new floors (the wood laminate that is now in the apartment is pretty damaged). The least expensive two bedroom is on the 31st floor and is offered for $429,900 with marble floors. The most expensive two bedroom is the same floor plan on the 36th floor for $525,000 that has been completely remodeled.
On the west side, we have seen 3 closed sales since the beginning of the year. These have closed at an average of $323/square foot and the sellers have received an average of 96% of their asking price. The least expensive was unit 1602, which is a 1 bedroom that sold for $260,000. I found the listing photos of this unit to be very misleading. The agent took photos of the bay view from the pool deck but did not specify that they were not taken from the unit itself. An uneducated or underrepresented buyer could easily be led astray with photos like this. Tsk tsk.
There are not any sales listings that currently have pending contracts. I have a feeling we will see some price reductions from those who need to sell.
SOUTH FACING UNITS
The south side of the building is interesting because Aria on the Bay is being constructed next door, so many of the sellers purchased their units when the view was very much different. The view is still pretty, just the water view is not as expansive as it once was. There are currently 8 available sales at an average price per foot of $343. The only closed sale this year in this section of the building was unit 2212, which is a 1,374 square foot 2 bedroom layout that sold for $435,000 ($316/square foot).
Just a few floors up, unit 2712 is currently awaiting closing and was listed for $324/square foot. Since buyers are settling for 96% of the asking price, it looks like we're due for some price reductions before things start to move.
EAST FACING UNITS
The east view at 1800 Club is really a money-maker. All of the plans on the east side are 2 bedroom layouts and 11 are currently available at an average price of $488/square foot. The actual listing prices are $489,000 up to $620,000.
Something interesting that I found is that the only closed sale on this side of the building was unit 1807, which closed for $545,000 ($445/square foot). The lowest price of the available units is unit 1403, a 2 bedroom with 1,142 square feet for $489,000 ($428/square foot). DEAL ALERT!!!
There are two 3 bedroom units available, but I really don't have anything to compare them to. One is a furnished 01 line that is on the 8th floor (below the pool deck). The other is a 3,082 square foot duplex loft on the pool level. They are listed for $975,000 and $1.29 million, respectively.
Overall, the building is looking at 27 months of inventory based upon closed sales rates. While that's not a great number, it is far healthier than some of the other buildings we've dug into over recent weeks. There have been a total of 6 closed sales in the overall building with an average price of $328/square foot. With 3 closings on the west side, one on the east side, one on the north side and one that was an outlier (it was on level 3 with a very different floor plan), the less expensive west side is the busier side currently. Since there is nothing pending over there at this point, it will be interesting to see what the summer brings us.
WHAT ABOUT RENTALS?
Just like the buildings we've seen over recent weeks, the rental market is still healthy at 1800 Club. There is just under 4 months of inventory on the market (20 active listings and 24 have rented since the beginning of the year). The listings are fetching 99% of their asking price and the listings are staying active for just under 60 days on average.
Now as an investor, you're probably thinking that 60 days is a long marketing period but also consider that many of the listings are activated 30 days before the previous tenant vacates. The paperwork process of moving a new tenant into the building typically takes 3 weeks, so the 60 days on the market statistic isn't really so bad.
One bedrooms are fetching $1,750/month and up right now, two bedrooms with west views are bringing $2,450/month. The only north facing unit that is available is an enormous 1,810 square foot 2 bedroom that is available for $3,500/month. East views are available for $2,800/month.
From an investment standpoint, I'm giving 1800 Club a gold star. Mortgages are available in the building, layouts are attractive to tenants (and owner/occupants), the building is well-run, the finishes are nice, the location is top notch and the views are beautiful. Pretending that we purchased that $260,000 one bedroom (the least expensive recent sale) and leased it for $1,750/month (the least expensive 1 bedroom recent rental), it would work out to a 4-5% return rate after expenses. Those are really great numbers for the area!
Which building should we look into next week???
Fantastic analysis of The 1800 Club.
Job well done. I particularly think the views are a lot better then those at Quantum due to the more frontal positioning of its structure in reference to the bay and the park. Better more efficient run building.
I’m glad you enjoyed it! You’re right about the building management. If I owned a bay view condo at 1800 Club, I’d switch out the brass faucets, but that’s just a personal thing. The building is top-notch!
Yup. The faucets and certain bathroom fixtures and little details could be changed
But the building is the best bang 4 ur buck in east Edgewater right now
Cheers
hi
A few years ago I looked at a 1 br @1800 club as a possible investment and was amazed at the OVERSTATEMENT of square footage in the small west facing units
First I subtracted the balcony footage
If memory serves me correctly they appeared to measure from the far edges of the unexpected large dark black rectangle that wrapped around the interior space so that the black wraparound was included in the total sq footage!
Removing balcony and black space measurements you were looking at more like 700+- sq ft of livable area nowhere near 840
The large one bedroom facing south was accurately portrayed
According to the floor plans and tax roll, the balcony square footage is separate from the living space (around 160sf). It could be that they calculate the square footage from the studs, which wold leave a few inches around the apartment.
Or sometimes the spaces feel smaller if they’re unfurnished or overly furnished. Could that be the case?
Should’ve made an appraisal and or survey to ratify actual s/c sq.ft
In any case I THINK The 1800 Club is the best bang 4 ur buck in east Edgewater
The east units facing Biscayne bay are simply the best views in all East Edgewater
Cheers
Serious question, does anyone think that prices have dropped by at least 5% since 12 months ago in this building?